Supercite vs AthenaHQ
Supercite costs a third of AthenaHQ's paid plan and gives you more answers: 6,000 a month for $95 against 3,600 for $295, plus articles written and published to your site. AthenaHQ is the pick if you need to track 11 models, including Perplexity and Claude.
Updated · Numbers from athenahq.ai/pricing
Where Supercite comes out ahead
$95 vs $295
entry price for a paid plan
6,000 vs 3,600
AI answers a month on the entry plan
10 a month
finished articles published to your site, not suggestions
Supercite is the better fit if
- You want more answers for less: 6,000 a month from $95
- You want finished articles published to your site, not optimization suggestions
- You want a fixed plan rather than a credit balance
AthenaHQ may suit you better if
- You need Perplexity, Claude, Copilot, Grok, DeepSeek or Meta AI tracked
- You want to start on a free plan
- You want on-page and off-page recommendations from a content agent
Features and pricing
Supercite and AthenaHQ, side by side
| Feature | Supercite | AthenaHQ |
|---|---|---|
| Price | ||
| Entry price | $95/mo, or $79/mo paid yearly | Free plan; paid from $295/mo |
| Free trial | Yes (included) | Free plan with 300 credits (included) |
| Tracking | ||
| Prompts on the entry plan | 50 | Credit-based: 1 credit = 1 AI response |
| AI answers a month, entry plan | 6,000 | 3,600 on Starter ($295/mo) |
| AI engines included | ChatGPT, Gemini, AI Overviews and AI Mode, on every plan (included) | 11 models on Starter, incl. Perplexity, Claude, Copilot, Grok (included) |
| How often prompts run | Daily | Set by your credits |
| Countries | Any country, in its language (included) | Country-level on Starter; multi-region on Enterprise |
| Content | ||
| Articles written for you | 10 a month on Starter, 30 on Growth, 60 on Scale (included) | Content optimization agent (partly, or at extra cost) |
| Publishes to your site | WordPress, Webflow, Framer, Shopify, Ghost (included) | Not listed on pricing page |
| Team and data | ||
| Team seats | Unlimited (included) | Unlimited (included) |
| API access | No, CSV export only (not included) | Paid add-on (partly, or at extra cost) |
| Also worth knowing | ||
| What $295 buys | 6,000 answers/mo + 30 articles on Growth ($245) (included) | 3,600 answers/mo |
Prices and plans checked on from athenahq.ai/pricing. Spotted something out of date? Tell us and we'll fix it.
In detail
How they differ
01Credits versus prompts
AthenaHQ sells credits: one credit is one AI response. Its Starter plan gives 3,600 a month for $295, which is 30 prompts run daily on 4 engines, or fewer prompts on more engines. Unused credits roll over for a month.
Supercite sells prompts. Starter's 50 prompts run on all four engines every day, which is 6,000 answers a month for $95.
02Models
Athena's Starter covers 11 models: ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overviews, AI Mode, Gemini, Claude, Copilot, Grok, DeepSeek, Meta AI and Mistral. If your buyers use Perplexity or Claude heavily, that breadth matters.
Supercite covers ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AI Overviews and Google AI Mode, and runs every prompt on all four.
03Suggestions versus published articles
Athena's content agent optimizes pages and suggests on-page and off-page actions. Supercite writes the article itself, for the questions where competitors are recommended and you aren't, from the pages AI already cites, and publishes it to WordPress, Webflow, Framer, Shopify or Ghost.
04The pages to get on
In our study of 839 AI answers, 90% of the brands AI recommended were on a "best X" list the engine cited for that answer. Supercite lists every cited page that doesn't mention you yet, so off-page work starts with a list, not a guess.
Switching from AthenaHQ
Up and running in five minutes
- 1
Enter your website
Supercite reads it and works out what you sell and who you compete with.
- 2
Check the prompts
We suggest the questions your buyers ask AI. Edit them, or add the ones you already track in AthenaHQ.
- 3
See today's answers
Your first answers from ChatGPT, Gemini, AI Overviews and AI Mode arrive the same day. Articles follow on autopilot.
Buying guide
Four questions to ask any AI visibility tool
Whichever you pick. They come from what we found when we read the pages AI cites.
- 1
Does it show you the pages AI reads?
In our study of 839 AI answers, 90% of the brands AI recommended were on a “best X” list the engine cited for that answer. Brands on none were recommended 2.5% of the time. A score without those pages leaves out the part you can act on.
- 2
Which engines are included, and which cost extra?
ChatGPT and Google's AI read different sources: Google's engines cite YouTube and Reddit, while ChatGPT cited neither in our data. Make sure the engines your buyers use are in the plan price, not an add-on.
- 3
What happens after the dashboard?
Knowing you're missing from an answer is step one. Someone still has to write the page or pitch the list. Decide whether you want a tool that tells you, or one that also does it.
- 4
Is the history real?
AI answers change from day to day. Look for prompts run on a fixed schedule with every answer stored, so a change in your numbers means the answers changed, not the sample.
FAQ
Supercite vs AthenaHQ: common questions
How much does AthenaHQ cost?
AthenaHQ has a free Essential plan with 300 credits, a Starter plan at $295 a month with 3,600 credits, and custom Enterprise pricing. One credit is one AI response.
Is Supercite cheaper than AthenaHQ?
Yes, at the entry level: $95 a month for 6,000 AI answers on four engines plus 10 published articles, against $295 for 3,600 answers on AthenaHQ's Starter.
Which tracks more AI models?
AthenaHQ: 11 on Starter. Supercite tracks four: ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AI Overviews and Google AI Mode.
