95%
What it is
Gemini is two things. It's a family of AI models made by Google, and it's Google's chatbot, at gemini.google.com and in the Gemini app. The chatbot was called Bard until early 2024.
The same models also write Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode. So Gemini shapes what millions of people see in Google search, even if they never open the chatbot.
How it picks brands
Gemini searches Google before answering most buying questions. It reads the top results and writes from them. In our study:
- It leans hard on fresh lists. 83% of the pages Gemini cited had "2026" in the title or URL.
- It rarely cites brand sites. When it recommended a brand, it cited that brand's own site only 5% of the time.
- It changes the most. 95% of its answers named a different set of brands the next day, and it dropped a third of the brands it had named.
How to show up
- Get onto current "best X" lists, especially ones with this year in the title.
- Rank in Google. Gemini reads Google results, so good SEO still helps.
- Track it daily. With answers this changeable, one check tells you almost nothing.
Example
Ask Gemini "best accounting software for a small business" on two days in a row. One day the answer might name QuickBooks, Xero, FreshBooks and Wave. The next day, QuickBooks, Xero, Zoho Books and Sage.
Two brands stayed. Two swapped out. That's a normal day on Gemini.
Frequently asked questions
Is Gemini the same as AI Mode?
No. They use the same family of models, but AI Mode is part of Google Search and runs many searches per question. In our study they often gave different recommendations for the same question.
Does blocking Google-Extended keep me out of Gemini?
It stops Google using your pages to train Gemini, and for some Gemini features. It doesn't remove you from AI Overviews or AI Mode, which use Google's normal search crawler.
Why does Gemini change its answers so much?
It reads fresh search results each time and picks from many similar lists. Small changes in what it finds lead to different brands.